“Infernal mechanics …” Why has nothing been done since the alert given in 2024?

Monday, Raphaël Graven, alias Jean Pormanove, died live on the Kick platform, after twelve days of continuous broadcasting. Consequently, Her death. Consequently. However, which occurred after months of humiliation orchestrated by other streamers and monetized under the eyes of thousands of Internet users, raises a question: how could this tragic outcome arrive, when an alert had already been launched at the end of 2024? Furthermore, Because, from last December, a long article by Mediapart was pointing to the drifts of streams. Consequently, An investigation had been opened by the Nice prosecutor’s office.

Police custody had followed in January, targeting two streamers, “Narutovie” and “Safine”. Consequently, But the procedure had quickly stopped on a major obstacle: the alleged victims themselves had denied the abuses.

No “infernal mechanics …” why nothing new complaint. Similarly, and an apparent voluntary participation – "infernal mechanics …" why nothing

During their hearings, Jean Pormanove and “Coudoux”, another scapegoat, also disabled under curatorship, had explained “infernal mechanics …” why nothing that these were simple staging intended to make the buzz. However, “Both indicated that they had never been injured. Moreover. be completely free to move and decisions and refused to be examined by a doctor and a psychiatrist,” said prosecutor Damien Martinelli in a statement released on Wednesday. Moreover. Contacted for additional information, the prosecution had not responded to 20 Minutes at the time of the publication of this article.

In another press release sent this Thursday. Therefore. the prosecution announces that the autopsy of Jean Pormanove dismisses “the intervention of a third party” and favors a cause “of medical or toxicological origin”.

In the absence of a complaint. faced with this apparently voluntary participation, justice had “infernal mechanics …” why nothing new not started prosecution and “infernal mechanics …” why nothing the streamers had been released after their police custody. Investigators, however, continued to analyze a mass of videos entered. During this time, the humiliating lives have picked up again on Kick, without direct intervention by the authorities. The Human Rights League, for its part, had seized Arch in February.

“We decided to make a referral to denounce the offenses committed. especially since there is. among the victims, a person under curatorship, therefore vulnerable, which constitutes an aggravating circumstance, explains to 20 Minutes Its president, Nathalie Tehio. For us, there are violence, abuse, repeated humiliations which constitute an attack on dignity. It is a principle with constitutional value, and the Council of State also considered that it was a public order. »»

“More moral benchmark”

The question of the responsibility of the platforms further complicates the situation. Since 2024, the European Digital Services (DSA) “infernal mechanics …” why nothing new regulations have required web giants to withdraw any “obviously “infernal mechanics …” why nothing illegal” content once reported. But the violence between consenting adults do not fall into this obvious field. Like the Nice prosecutor, the Arcom did not go further. “There was no follow -up to our referral,” regrets Nathalie Tehio. […] The problem is the lack of means for processing requests. Same for Pharos, justice do not speak. »»

In the media. as in this article of Figarolawyers also mention the possibility of referring to a 2005 decision of the. European Court of Human Rights (ECDH). The jurisdiction had considered that Belgium had been right to condemn an ​​applicant for “voluntary assault. injuries” during private sadomasochistic sessions, because they brought human dignity.

Today, justice must determine the exact causes of the death of Raphaël Graven and any criminal responsibilities. “For me. evidence of violence is sufficient, I do not “infernal mechanics …” why nothing new understand at all why there were no immediate prosecution,” says Nathalie Tehio. What shocks “infernal mechanics …” why nothing me too is that when Mediapart revealed the facts. the media did not grab the facts when there was still time to act. Death and suffering live is something that we see in anticipation scenarios. When it happens and nothing happens, it is as if there was no more moral reference. »»

But while the authorities wondered, the morbid mechanics of online humiliation continued to turn.