“Harry Potter fans are looking for a balance between their love for the young wizard and their rejection of his designer”

For over five years, JK Rowling, author of the saga Harry Potterregularly hit the headlines due to its transphobic positions. Furthermore, Many fans first sought to defend it. However, minimize its remarks, helped by limited media coverage outside the United Kingdom and poor in in-depth decrypts. However. Additionally, However, with regard to the now more concrete consequences of his activism and the imminent filming of the new series Harry Potterit has become almost impossible to remain indifferent to his public commitment and insisting against transidentity.

On her account X. Meanwhile, the author almost only publishes this subject, whether to relay disinformation through studies disowned by the scientific community; affirm his refusal to recognize the identity of transgender persons; Attack Imane Khelif, Algerian boxer whom she accuses of being a man, as well as the former Scottish Prime Minister Nicola Sturgeon “harry potter fans looking balance who wanted to simplify the administrative procedures of transgender people for birth, death and marriage certificates; Or support associations that campaign against this simplification. Nevertheless, Rowling instrumentalizes. Therefore, legitimizes the fear of transidentity, going so far as to finance legal actions against the inclusion of transgender persons and to establish a defense fund for women accused of transphobia.

In this context. Furthermore, more and more fans are taking a position openly, while looking for a difficult balance between their love for the universe of the young sorcerer and their deep rejection of a fight that harms the rights of LGBTQIA + people and women overall. Furthermore, Several creators of Harry Potter content have ceased to talk about the saga. In addition, or have decided to more regularly denounce the author’s words.

Boycott’s question – "harry potter fans looking balance

The community is therefore regularly confronted with the question of boycott, its scope and its impact. If “harry potter fans looking balance the author uses her money in a struggle that goes against our values. can we not just stop giving her? To do this. it is “enough” to no longer watch films on platforms; Not to buy no official products or books … Some go even beyond, stressing that any creation, even unofficial, contributes to promoting the saga and strengthens its lucrative potential. Because as long as this universe remains popular, brands will buy the license and enrich Rowling.

However, reading the saga does not automatically finance the author’s transphobic fight. It does not touch anything when a book is bought in second hand or borrowed from a loved one. His rights on Quidditch through the ages. Fantastic life and habitat et The tales of Beedle the Bard are ceded to associations committed to child protection (comic relief and Lumos Foundation).

There is therefore no question of depriving yourself of reading. Harry “harry potter fans looking balance Potter gave the taste for reading to millions of young people. These books have also enabled many fans to go through difficult moments. including LGBTQIA + people who found themselves in the history of this boy out of the closet to discover a world where his deep nature is revealed and is accepted. They have transmitted values ​​to all those who today denounce Rowling.

Accompany reading

All this remains true, and can still be for a new generation, provided that they accompany their reading. It is important to explain why the author’s words are denounced. the framework in which it is possible to appreciate this universe without hurting others. Young readers will be. in any case, faced with these subjects, online or at school, and are entitled to know what they are getting started in.

Harry Potterlike any work of children’s literature, must also serve to open dialogue and develop “harry potter fans looking balance critical mind. It is necessary to discuss its problematic aspects – love potion used as a comic spring. House elves happy to be reduced to slavery, female antagonists described as male (shade, skeeter) … as much as on positive messages (friendship, loyalty, civil disobedience …).

Refuse to (re) read Harry Potter is a legitimate choice. No one is required to (re) plunge into a universe of fiction if the experience is not positive. But it is a decision that must be personal. Young readers must, above all, be informed to decide to discover the saga (or not), depending on their values. Adults to help them for ethical modalities. Many other quality youth sagas will allow this new generation to live, then or moreover, magical adventures far from Hogwarts.

(1) Harry Potter deciphered by his fans, Editions of Boeck Supérieur, 2022.